|
The content of these pages is copyright © 1999-2007 by "KFC
Cinema" and may not be copied or reprinted without the written consent
of the publisher.
This site is in no way affiliated with Kentucky Fried
Chicken"...
Copyright © Kung Fu Cult Cinema Ltd.
All other copyrights belong to their relevant owners,
if you hold the copyright to something and would like it to be removed,
then mail us.
|
 |
| |
Eat
Drink Man Woman
 |
|
Country
: |
Taiwan/China |
| Year: |
1994 |
| Genre: |
Drama |
| Format: |
DVD |
| Running
Time: |
2H04 |
| Distributor: |
MGM |
| Date
reviewed: |
08/25/2002 |
| |
|
| Producer: |
Kong
Hsu, Li-Kong Hsu |
| Director: |
Ang
Lee |
Cast: Sihung Lung, Yu-Wen Wang,
Chien-lien Wu, Kuei-Mei Yang, Sylvia Chang, Winston Chao,
Chao-jung Chen, Lester Chit-Man Chan, Yu Chen, Ah Lei
Gua, Chi-Der Hong, Gin-Ming Hsu |
|
|
|
Story:
The Chu house consist of four family members: a windowed
highly-renowned chef, an oldest daughter who is a school
teacher, a middle-child who is an airline executive,
a youngest daughter who is still a college student making
her transaction into the real world. Together, they
seek out the recipe for love.
Review: Eat Drink Man Woman reunites the
Ang Lee with the crew of the critically acclaimed
The Wedding Banquet and also his first film to feature
his native country of Taiwan. Featuring a cast of
all Taiwanese actors, this is truly a pure and genuine
Taiwanese film. The country of Taiwan hasn't been
blessed with a plethora of budding film talents as
the other countries of Japan, Korea, and Hong Kong
(China). Most of the critical and commercial success
of Chinese cinema is limited to the films made by
Hong Kong. When Ang Lee emerged into the scene with
Pushing Hands, the eyes of the film world turned to
him. Then when The Wedding Banquet came out, those
eyes began to praise him. His follow-up to his success
was Eat Drink Man Woman and right after that film,
he exploded into American film scene and made three
films before establishing himself as a powerhouse
filmmaker with Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. With
Eat Drink Man Woman, he is giving the world a taste
of the culture and essence of Taiwan.
Food serves as the ultimate motif for this film.
From the saliva-inducing opening to the gentle but
full of warmth closing, food not only gives the cast
of this film a full stomach, but also plays a pivotal
in each of their lives. Chef Chu is the father to
three very different daughters: the hapless in love
oldest daughter, the stunningly beautiful mid-child
who can't seem to get a break in love and life, and
the full of youth youngest daughter who has not yet
become a woman yet. The core cast of this film does
an amazing job convincing us of their family love
and rivalries. From love to hate, each emotion is
played out with such style and ambiance, that you
feel the emotions running through the room. However,
that is not to say that the acting is not flawed.
For the people who can understand Mandarin, the first
ten or so minutes serves and an enduring trial. For
some reason, some of the voice acting in those beginning
minutes were simply terrible. The conversations seemed
forced and the tones of their voices was bland (For
the non-Mandarin speakers and listeners, this won't
prove to be a problem since their facial reactions
are flawless). While seeing this film for the first
time, I was hoping that this was not the case for
the rest of the movie. Luckily, it wasn't. Each characters
voice acting improves, contributing to the beautiful
performances they deliver. When all seems well with
the core cast's acting, the supporting cast begins
to sprout up. From the "witchy" mother of
their friend to the confused lover the youngest daughter
converses with, the supporting cast only adds spice
to the already flavorful cast.
The story itself is something else however. Never
have I been so ambiguous about a movie's story. It's
a tale of three daughters and their father finding
love in their own unique ways while discovering themselves
and boding with each other. The story presents the
ideal opportunity for the actors to work up a beautiful
chemistry with each other. In some cases, the chemistry
is done with shameless talent, but there's also others
in which is lacks thereof. This brings up the most
negative thing about Eat Drink Man Woman.
An example is this: the youngest daughter doesn't
share many scenes with her family except around the
dinner table. Her chemistry with her sisters therefore
is downplayed. However, she makes up for it by having
great chemistry with the hopeless lover. Also, there's
practically no scenes featuring Chu and the nearby
neighbor. Why do these empty holes prove to be such
a problem? Halfway through the movie, the story begins
to drop shock bombs on you. Out of no where, a family
member will announce a new critical detail in their
search for love. Now, this wouldn't bother me so much,
but it does because there is practically no build-up
to it! I don't know if that was Ang Lee's intention,
to make the news just as much of a surprise to the
audience as it is to the people in the film, but it
gives the film a very unsettling soap opera undertone.
From the youngest daughters first obscure news, to
the father's extremely bizarre decision in the end,
this movie is saturated with juicy soap opera shocks.
Every time it happens, you'll be caught off guard.
It also contradicts the whole message of taking your
time to find true love. For me personally, this just
didn't sit in my stomach right. They spend so much
time in this film building up the search for the recipe
of love, and to give us the outcome in such a hasty
and obscure manner isn't my cup of tea. It's like
studying a certain dish for months, and then making
that dish in less than five minutes. However, others
might find the sudden news delightful. I just felt
cheated with an outcome that left much to be desired.
That's the one part of the film that left a bad aftertaste
in my mouth.
Perhaps the biggest forte of this film is Ang Lee's
ability to take his camera and capture the beauty
of Taiwan. He shows us the streets of Taiwan, the
kitchens of Taiwan, the apartments of Taiwan, the
countrysides of Taiwan, and so much more. Being from
Taiwan myself, the scenery gave me a fresh taste of
something I had seen so many times in my life, yet
it was served to me with such delicacy, it was like
a new experience. The shots of food preparation just
stimulates your taste buds unmercifully. You'll long
for Chinese food after seeing this movie. Not many
films are able to display the traditions and essence
of Taiwan with such precision (Back in the 70s and
80s, there was a rash of films that did the job).
With films giving us insight into Japanese culture
and Korean culture, it was pleasant to see a film
that gave the world an accurate depiction to the culture
of Taiwan. Although it has many positive attributes,
Eat Drink Man Woman isn't Ang Lee's best work. However,
it's still an enjoyable film about family, friendship,
and most importantly of all, food.
There was a calling card for a talented director
from Taiwan who also has a knack for capturing mood
and emotion with dead accuracy with a camera. That
calling card was answered by Ang Lee. He's already
wowed the Asian audiences and wooed the American audience.
All eyes are once again turned to Ang Lee to see what
new piece of cinema he will provide for the world.
|






|
DVD
[ NTSC, Region 1
] :
MGM managed to put together a decent DVD for this
film. The picture quality and sound is great, making
the opening credits of the film even more hunger-inducing.
Never have I seen subtitles so perfectly translated
before. High praise for those who did the translation
for this film. The extra features include two trailers
for the movie and a 15 minutes or so interview with
director Ang Lee. It's worth the price if you decide
to purchase this film.
Reviewed
by JoE Shieh
|
| Story |
Cast |
Entertainment |
Subtitles |
Overall |
| 3.5 |
3.5 |
4 |
5 |
3.5 |

|
|
 |
| © 1999-2003 by KFC
Cinema. All rights reserved. |
|
|
|
|