|
The content of these pages is copyright © 1999-2007 by "KFC
Cinema" and may not be copied or reprinted without the written consent
of the publisher.
This site is in no way affiliated with Kentucky Fried
Chicken"...
Copyright © Kung Fu Cult Cinema Ltd.
All other copyrights belong to their relevant owners,
if you hold the copyright to something and would like it to be removed,
then mail us.
|
 |
| |
Kill
Bill Vol. 1 and 2
 |
|
Country
: |
USA |
| Year: |
2003
/ 2004 |
| Genre: |
Chambara
/ Kung Fu / Action |
| Format: |
DVD
/ Theater |
| Running
Time: |
1H51
/ 2H10 |
| Distributor: |
Miramax
Films |
| Date
reviewed: |
04/14/04 |
| |
|
| Producer: |
Lawrence
Bender |
| Director: |
Quentin
Tarantino |
Cast: Uma Thurman, Lucy Liu,
Michael Madsen, Darryl Hannah, Gordon Liu, David Carradine,
Chiaki Kuriyama, Sonny Chiba, Kenji Ohba, Vivica A. Fox
|
|
|
|
Story:
Uma Thurman plays 'The Bride" who takes revenge
against Bill and his Deadly Viper Assassination Squad
for putting a slug in her head prior to her wedding,
bun in the oven and all. Genres are meshed together
as Tarantino chronicles her blood soaked journey, scratching
names off of her 'Death List" all the way home.
Review: To kick this off bluntly, this film
shouldn't have been cut into two parts. It's hard
to judge one half on its own merit when one volume
of the movie strengthens and plays off of the other
so much. It's also hard now to get it out of my mind
as two movies. All this aside, watching vol. 2 has
made me appreciate the first half much more, and I
think there's something in the second half for those
that weren't too impressed with the first.
Tarantino loves to show us how big of a film buff
he is. His love for asian cinema, though perhaps not
as aptly displayed in his real life decisions, is
seen consistently throughout "Kill Bill",
but it doesn't just stop with the East. His fourth
film references and is influenced by a myriad of cult
films, and is as much, if not more a Western than
it is anything else. "Kill Bill" is Tarantino's
gushing nerd orgasm. This is the movie that you exasperatingly
explain to someone in concept on the playground while
walking between the slide and the swings. The characters
are your "cowboys and indians" sets to which
you'll arbitrarily choose your friends to play during
recess.
At least this applies to the first volume. But let's
not get ahead of ourselves.
I'll try and keep this review as chronological as
possible, contrary to the style in which "Kill
Bill" unfolds. The order in which the Bride takes
down the members of the Deadly Viper Assassination
Squad on her "Death List" is mixed up in
the film, but this is more for effect than anything.
For instance, were Uma and Vivica's showdown the climax
of Volume One, the impact of the cliffhanger would
have been softened a great deal.
Volume one introduces us to the Bride (Thurman),
Vernita Green (Fox), O-Ren Ishii (Liu) and Elle Driver
(Hannah) as far as the main players go. Bill (Carradine)
is restricted to more of a "Dr. Claw" role
as the voice calling the shots, and Budd (Madsen)
also doesn't truly get his time in the spotlight until
the second volume. Characters in the first film are
very cut and paste, and the audience doesn't know
much if anything about them. Even with O-Ren Ishii's
animated backstory (which is a beautifully executed
segment of Ishii beautifully executing people, and
a true highlight), she's still a fairly cardboard
character, though this doesn't make her section of
the movie any less entertaining. It might be due to
the fact that those surrounding Liu stand out so much
more, including most members of the Crazy 88, but
more specifically Go Go Yubari. Lucy Liu just doesn't
work for me in this role. She's not horrible, but
there was no feeling in her performance. O-Ren Ishii
could have been played by anyone else with equal or
better results.
Most of the other characters in volume one are equally
flat, including the Bride herself, who at this point
is just a revenge driven killing machine. It isn't
until we learn more about the characters in volume
two that they become less like pages out of random
comic books and fall more into their own territory.
This is both good and bad. In all seriousness, volume
one is hugely entertaining by itself. Though it leaves
a gaping hole, it's enjoyable in a pure visceral action
sort of way. It's insanely entertaining to watch Uma
chop limbs off for an hour and a half, tearing down
the house in the most literal sense. There's not much
to be said in volume one, it pretty much speaks for
itself. This isn't the dialogue driven film Tarantino
fans may expect.
There really isn't a whole lot of talking in the first
half at all, at least not as much as I would expect.
What is said in the first film, especially by Uma,
is sometimes awkward. Specifically in her honorable
tone which sounds more like cue card reading than
anything. This problem (if you can call it that) was
rectified in volume two, which I'll get to in a moment.
Talky aspects aside, much if not all of the intensity
can be credited to Yuen Wo-Ping's martial arts advising
and his staging of the action scenes, which are for
the most part excellent. The culmination of the action
in the film is the House of Blue Leaves fight, which
leaves almost nothing to be desired in my opinion
(aside from the color presented in the Japanese cut).
The pace of this scene is perfect, with the Crazy
88 members coming slowly, one at a time at first.
Chiaki Kuriyama then gets her moment as Go Go Yubari,
implementing her pseudo-flying guillotine against
Uma in one of the highlights of both halves, despite
its brevity. After this, all hell breaks loose in
the House of Blue Leaves, with limbs and heads flying
chambara style, equally violent and hilarious.
Don't forget...Sonny Chiba.
Once volume one ends, throughout
the sense of awe there's an inevitably empty feeling;
like eating cereal without milk. The first volume
is good, but the anticipation to see what happens
next is absolutely killer.
So volume two doesn't fall under the same scrutiny
as a sequel, but more of a foggy-eyed curiosity, like
you were watching a good action flick and you slipped
into a coma halfway through that lasted for months.
Waking up from the coma puts you in familiar territory,
with a brief prologue for those that forgot what happened
in the first movie.
Exploring the relationship between the Bride and Bill
is key to the second half of the movie. Bill is no
longer a mr. x who seems to have pointlessly ruined
Uma's life beyond repair. Closer examination of the
attempted murder of the Bride and the absolute massacre
of her entire wedding rehearsal party proves otherwise.
Bill has heart and is far from your typical villain.
It's in this that the relationship between "good"
and "bad" in "Kill Bill" becomes
more ambiguous. Seeing both sides of the story can
make you question who's right and who's wrong. Hell,
I like Bill. I like him a lot. He's a great character
and I can see why he did what he did, even if it did
go a bit beyond "overreacting", as he so
eloquently puts it.
The dialogue in volume two feels much more Tarantino.
While in the first volume I just wanted everyone to
shut up and fight, this time around I was much more
interested in what the characters had to say, though
here and there a conversation or two tended to overstay
their welcome. This and a myriad of other elements
make it much different than its prior portion. While
the splitting may have contributed to this feeling,
both volumes at times seem to be veering off in different
directions at a roads fork.
With Bill as the films main focus, the rest of the
confrontational duties fall on the shoulders of Michael
Madsen's Budd and Darryl Hannah's Elle Driver. Budd's
character is great, but there's something about his
parts of the film that feels like it could have stood
more cutting in the editing room. It's not boring,
but some bits and pieces of volume two wouldn't have
suffered if shortened. Elle Driver, on the other hand,
scores one of the most brutal and exciting fights
of both halves. She's a vicious woman, a total bitch.
That's Elle in a nutshell. Not only is Uma her rival
as a warrior, but essentially Elle is only with Bill
because of The Bride's prolonged absence. Playing
second fiddle, whether Bill openly expressed it or
not, can do a lot to someone with such inherent intensity.
In the same way that the anime sequence in volume
one showed a flashback through a memorable and exciting
method, volume two has Pai Mei. While it's not animated,
Gordon Liu as Pai Mei is another show-stopper that
dominates any recollection of "Kill Bill"
as a whole. His ruthless training is a melting pot
of everything you love about kung fu films, Liu confidently
stroking his long white beard prior to each transition,
slyly cackling. If it were but a bit longer...sigh.
The only true disappointment that I found in "Kill
Bill" was its finale. It's just a bit anticlimactic,
though I'll delve no further for the sake of those
who have yet to see it. Despite this minor gripe,
at the end of the day "Kill Bill" is still
a thoroughly enjoyable film that occasionally gets
a tad eccentric in its shouting out to as many movies
as Tarantino could be bothered to remember that he
loves. Sometimes I wonder when one should draw the
line with the amount of references in a flick. Tarantino
should especially be kissing Lady Snowblood's foot
for the contribution she made to "Kill Bill"s
plot.
The soundtrack is great, with only a few dubious placement
choices. How hard is it to take songs from other sources
and drop them in where you feel it's called for, though?
I guess it's hard enough to require the Rza's assistance,
though he did drop some original work, however sparingly.
Great cinematography and some well-written dialogue
(specifically for the second half) really round out
the films as one whole. Perhaps the final product
would have been a bit slicker had Tarantino been forced
to cut the wind of it all down to a tolerable single
film with a running time of around two and a half
hours. Who knows, who cares? People that like volume
one may hate volume two and vice versa, but I strongly
urge those who haven't seen it to give it a go, it's
definitely worth the time (and the unfortunate price
of two admissions).
|








|
DVD
[ NTSC, Region 1
] :
Kill Bill Volume One-The first dvd
to come out for the films first volume is forgettable,
and only recommended to those who don't plan on waiting
for the inevitable one million other future releases.
The film does look and sound great; 2.35:1 16x9 enhanced
Widescreen. 5.1 surround and DTS tracks, multiple sub
choices and all that jazz. On the other hand, the disc
is more bare than a hobo on a holiday. Extras include
a making of featurette, bonus musical performances by
"The 5,6,7,8's" and Quentin Tarantino movie
trailers: lame. I say hold out for a future release
or get the Japanese disc in its uncut gore glory.
Reviewed
by Joseph Luster
|
| Story |
Cast |
Entertainment |
Subtitles |
Overall |
| 3 |
3.5 |
4 |
n/a |
4 |

|
|
 |
| © 1999-2003 by KFC
Cinema. All rights reserved. |
|
|
|
|